Authentic Italian Flavor
Right Here in Emmitsburg
Carleo Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria has been feeding Emmitsburg since 2004 — NY-style pizza, homemade pasta, stacked subs and the steak & cheese people drive for. Dine in, take out, get it delivered, or let us cater.
The Daily Special
2 large 16″ cheese pizzas + a 2-liter Coca-Cola product. The deal Emmitsburg runs on — feed the whole crew without cooking a thing.
$24.99
Known For the good stuff
The plates reviewers name-check: homemade lasagna with huge portions, steak & cheese subs, a sweeter pizza sauce, and staff who treat you like a regular — because around here, you probably are one.
NY-Style PizzaPizza, by the slice or the pie
Cheese, specialty pies and a 16″ stuffed pizza — plus eight specialty pies from Hawaiian to Taco.
Famous SubsSteak & cheese, done right
The steak & cheese hoagie and steak & cheese fries are the ones people talk about. Twenty-plus subs deep.
Save RoomCheesecake & cannoli
Cheesecake plain or with strawberry or chocolate drizzle — and yes, there are cannoli.
VisitOn the Silo Hill strip
A small dining room, a booming takeout counter, and twenty-plus years on Silo Hill Road.
Lunch, handled
Lunch combos every day until 2:00 PM — order the priced combos online, or call them in.
2 Slices + Fountain Drink
$7.50
Pepperoni Roll + Drink
$9.99
Small Sub Combo
$12.99
Large Sub Combo
$13.99
That has been the Carleo way since 2004. Come hungry.